Les Roka, editor of The Selective Echo and writer for The Utah Review, wrote this commentary:
Recently, KCPW-FM’s Roger McDonough interviewed Mark Alvarez
about the status of immigration reform for the half-hour public affairs show
‘The Rundown.’ Often, Mark speaks about the issue in Spanish-language media, but ‘The Rundown’ was an ideal platform to discuss
the issue not only in English but also within the contexts of national policy
and Utah politics. Likewise, Mark contributed numerous posts about immigration
to The Selective Echo, some of which have been collected in a Kindle e-book
entitled, ‘Becoming America: Selected readings on immigration from The Selective Echo.’
Mark’s voice on immigration is one that, unfortunately, has
been ignored all too frequently by the state’s policy and power community.
Every issue discussion should take into account discrete systemic, societal and
individual challenges that always should guide socially responsible and ethical
conversation and debate. However, in Utah, the predominant political party (the
Republicans) and the predominant religion (Mormons) persistently have ignored
or belittled the ideals of what truly effective reform would be. More
disturbingly, they have crafted empty self-serving PR narratives. As someone
who has worked and studied in media for more than 30 years, I have seen the Mormon-owned
media unabashedly enabling these dishonest efforts.
First, a group of LDS politicians and lobbyists plagiarized
in part and Mormonized the sincere ideals articulated in the 2009 Enriching
Utah Coalition values statement. Their result, published in November 2010, was
the derivative Utah Compact – merely a document of political convenience for Republicans
and the LDS Church.
Second, despite paying lip service to federal Constitutional
authority over immigration, Utah political and economic leaders pushed the
so-called “Utah Solution.” Legislators and the governor repeatedly ignored
warnings about unconstitutionality from legislative attorneys. On July 1, 2010,
on the Pulso Latino radio show co-hosted by Tony Yapias and Mark Alvarez,
Governor Gary Herbert said, “smart people like you [Mark] will make this [Utah
Solution] work.” Herbert ultimately relied on then-Attorney General Mark
Shurtleff – a complete failure of rigor. The result was unconstitutional laws,
one of which is tied up in court and another that has been delayed three times,
most recently until July 2017, to avoid embarrassing defeat in court. During
the 2014 legislative session, Utah State Senator Curt Bramble, a key backer of
the Utah Solution, acknowledged the law’s practical and legal problems.
The interview covers much ground – ranging from the current
stalemate in Congress over a bill that passed the U.S. Senate in June 2013 to
the recent discussion about deportation numbers and the options the President
has in advancing reform should the U.S. House of Representatives fail to act. Mark
and Roger also talk about the failure of Utah’s leaders in the GOP and LDS
communities to advocate honestly for reform, along with the deeply-rooted flaws
in the Utah scheme.
In Utah, there are two general narratives about immigration
reform. One is based on equivocation, a deliberate misappropriation of facts
and earnestly-stated values, and of PR optics for the sake of political
ambition and power. The other, which I believe Mark and Roger reflect
accurately in this interview, arises from a careful consideration of facts,
ethics, and values, especially in terms of how we proceed in crafting humane,
compassionate and constitutional immigration policy.
I encourage you to listen.
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario